Port Orford cedar is generally harder, heavier, and stronger than western red cedar. Western red cedar is lighter and widely used for siding, shingles, decking, and outdoor structures. Both woods have naturally decay-resistant heartwood, but their appearance, availability, and suitability differ by project.
Choosing between them involves more than comparing strength. For exterior siding, lightweight boards and available profiles may be your priorities. For arrow shafts, fine woodworking, or certain boat components, straight grain and mechanical properties may matter more.
Here is how Port Orford cedar and western red cedar compare.
What Is Port Orford Cedar?
Port Orford cedar (Chamaecyparis lawsoniana), also known as Lawson cypress, is an evergreen conifer native to southwestern Oregon and northwestern California.
Its wood is valued for its relatively high strength for its weight, straight grain, and natural decay resistance. Freshly worked lumber has a distinctive ginger-like fragrance.
Although its common name includes “cedar,” it belongs to the cypress family rather than the true cedar genus, Cedrus.
Traditional uses include arrow shafts, boatbuilding, interior joinery, and specialty woodworking. Selected timber has also been exported to Japan for religious buildings and other applications requiring high-quality wood.
What Is Western Red Cedar?
Western red cedar (Thuja plicata) is an evergreen conifer native to western North America. Other common names include Pacific red cedar and giant arborvitae.
The wood is lightweight, aromatic, and valued for its dimensional stability. Its heartwood has natural resistance to decay, making it useful for many exterior applications.
Western red cedar is particularly well known for siding, shingles, shakes, fencing, decking, and outdoor furniture. Carefully selected material is also used for musical instrument soundboards and boatbuilding.
Like Port Orford cedar, it belongs to the cypress family and is not a true Cedrus species.
Port Orford Cedar vs Western Red Cedar: Comparison Table
| Characteristic | Port Orford Cedar | Western Red Cedar |
|---|---|---|
| Scientific name | Chamaecyparis lawsoniana | Thuja plicata |
| Wood classification | Softwood | Softwood |
| Average dried weight | Approximately 29 lb/ft³ (465 kg/m³) | Approximately 23 lb/ft³ (370 kg/m³) |
| Janka hardness | Approximately 590 lbf (2,620 N) | Approximately 350 lbf (1,560 N) |
| Heartwood color | Pale yellowish-brown, sometimes with a pinkish tint | Reddish-brown to pinkish-brown, with considerable variation |
| Grain | Usually straight, with a relatively fine, even texture | Usually straight, with a somewhat coarser texture |
| Odor | Distinctive ginger-like scent | Characteristic cedar aroma |
| Natural decay resistance | Durable heartwood | Durable heartwood |
| Common uses | Arrow shafts, boat components, joinery, and specialty woodwork | Siding, shingles, decking, fencing, and outdoor furniture |
| Availability | More specialized and region-dependent | Generally more widely available as exterior building products |
These figures are typical averages. Individual boards vary with moisture content, growth conditions, and lumber quality.
Appearance and Color
Port Orford Cedar
Port Orford cedar generally has pale yellowish-brown heartwood, occasionally with a pinkish tint. Its sapwood is pale yellow to nearly white and may not be sharply separated from the heartwood.
The grain is usually straight, and the texture is relatively fine and uniform. This gives finished pieces a clean appearance, particularly when clear boards are selected.
Its pale color works well for interior trim, doors, and projects where a lighter wood is preferred.
Western Red Cedar
Western red cedar has a broader color range. Its heartwood can be pinkish-brown, reddish-brown, or darker brown, sometimes with noticeable streaks. The sapwood is much lighter.
This variation adds character to siding and furniture, although matching boards requires some selection.
Understanding the difference between heartwood and sapwood is also useful when buying either species for exterior work, because natural decay resistance mainly belongs to the heartwood.
Which Wood Is Harder and Stronger?
Port Orford cedar has a Janka hardness of approximately 590 lbf, compared with 350 lbf for western red cedar. It therefore offers greater resistance to indentation.
However, both are relatively soft compared with many furniture hardwoods. Either can dent under heavy impacts, concentrated loads, or careless handling.
Port Orford cedar also generally has higher bending strength and stiffness in comparable clear-wood tests. This does not mean that any Port Orford cedar board can replace a western red cedar structural component.
For beams, posts, and other load-bearing applications, the lumber grade, dimensions, connections, and design requirements determine suitability.
Which Wood Is More Stable?
Both species are valued for dimensional stability, but it is misleading to describe Port Orford cedar as automatically more stable.
Western red cedar has low shrinkage and is especially well regarded for remaining dimensionally stable as conditions change. Its stability is one reason it is widely used for exterior siding and trim.
Nevertheless, both woods absorb and release moisture. Neither is completely resistant to movement, checking, or warping.
For better results:
- Buy lumber with a moisture condition suitable for the project.
- Allow it to acclimate before installation.
- Store boards flat, supported, and protected from rain.
- Follow the required spacing and fastening instructions.
Durability and Rot Resistance
Both woods have naturally decay-resistant heartwood, but neither is waterproof or immune to rot.
Long-term performance depends on the amount of heartwood, lumber quality, moisture exposure, and construction details. Sapwood generally provides less natural protection against decay.
A well-drained board that dries between wet periods performs differently from one that remains damp against soil or trapped debris.
For exterior projects, design joints to shed water, provide ventilation, and avoid unnecessary ground contact. Use material specifically suitable for the intended exposure rather than assuming that every board labeled “cedar” will perform equally well.
Natural durability also should not be interpreted as guaranteed protection against every insect.
Common Uses of Port Orford Cedar
Arrow Shafts
Port Orford cedar has a long history of use for traditional wooden arrow shafts. Straight grain, manageable weight, and suitable mechanical properties make selected stock useful for this purpose.
Arrow-making requires carefully selected, straight-grained material; ordinary lumber is not automatically suitable.
Boatbuilding
Its combination of strength, workability, and decay-resistant heartwood makes it useful for selected boatbuilding components.
Suitability depends on the component and construction method. Marine use still requires appropriate design, fastening, and finishing.
Interior Joinery
The pale color and relatively fine texture suit doors, moldings, and other interior woodwork.
Specialty Woodworking
Selected boards may be used for musical instruments, decorative projects, and other applications where clear grain and appearance justify the cost.
Common Uses of Western Red Cedar
Siding, Shingles, and Shakes
Western red cedar is a familiar choice for exterior cladding because of its low weight, stability, and durable heartwood.
It is available in numerous profiles and grades, making it easier to source products intended for specific building applications.
Decking and Fencing
The wood is commonly used for deck boards, fence boards, and screens. Its softness is worth considering for surfaces exposed to heavy traffic, dragged furniture, or repeated impacts.
Outdoor Furniture
Western red cedar suits benches, garden furniture, and other projects where low weight and natural appearance are desirable.
Boatbuilding and Musical Instruments
Selected western red cedar is used for lightweight boat planking and musical instrument soundboards. These applications require suitable grain, grade, and dimensions.
Workability and Fastening
Both species are generally easy to cut, shape, and machine with sharp tools.
Working with Port Orford Cedar
Port Orford cedar usually machines cleanly and accepts glue and finishes well. Its straight grain helps when producing narrow components or detailed joinery.
Use sharp cutters and support thin sections to reduce splitting and tear-out.
Working with Western Red Cedar
Western red cedar is easy to handle because of its low weight, but it dents readily. Clamp pads and a clean work surface help protect finished faces.
Softness does not eliminate the need for pilot holes. Pre-drilling can be useful near board ends, in thin pieces, and when installing larger screws.
For exterior work, use suitable corrosion-resistant fasteners. Ordinary steel can cause staining and deterioration. The Western Red Cedar Lumber Association’s project guide recommends corrosion-resistant fasteners and identifies stainless steel as a preferred option, particularly for visible finishes.
Painting, Staining, and Maintenance
Both woods can be painted or stained when the surface is properly prepared.
Choose a finish intended for the species and application. Exterior siding, decking, and indoor furniture may require different products.
For painted work, use an appropriate primer, including stain-blocking protection where needed. For stained surfaces, test an offcut first because natural color differences affect the result.
Unfinished exterior wood generally weathers toward gray. If retaining the original color matters, use an appropriate pigmented exterior finish and maintain it according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
A finish slows weathering and moisture uptake, but it does not replace good drainage or make wood waterproof.
How to Identify the Trees
Wood color alone is not always enough to distinguish these species. When identifying a living tree, examine the foliage, bark, and cones together.
Port Orford Cedar Identification
- Scale-like leaves form flattened sprays.
- Foliage may be green or bluish-green, particularly among cultivated varieties.
- Mature bark becomes thick, ridged, and reddish-brown.
- Seed cones are small and rounded.
Port Orford cedar does produce cones containing seeds. It does not produce fleshy fruit like an apple tree. Oregon State University’s species profile provides photographs of its foliage, bark, and cones.
Western Red Cedar Identification
- Scale-like leaves grow in flattened sprays.
- Foliage is generally glossy green above, with pale markings underneath.
- Bark is fibrous and can separate into long strips.
- Seed cones are small and elongated, with overlapping scales.
Cultivated forms can look different from forest-grown trees, so avoid relying on tree shape alone.
Price and Availability
Port Orford cedar is generally a specialty timber, and availability can be limited outside its producing region. Clear, straight-grained material may carry a premium.
Western red cedar is more widely distributed as siding, decking, fencing, and dimensional lumber. However, clear grades and large sections can also be expensive.
Compare equivalent grades, sizes, and moisture conditions. A knotty fence board and a clear, kiln-dried joinery board are very different products.
Which Cedar Should You Choose?
Choose Port Orford cedar when you need a pale appearance, greater hardness, or selected straight-grained material for specialty woodworking.
Choose western red cedar when your priorities are low weight, dimensional stability, and access to established exterior products such as siding, shingles, and decking.
For either species, inspect the grade, heartwood content, moisture condition, and defects before buying. Those details often influence the finished project as much as the species itself.
Comments are closed.