Incense Cedar vs Western Red Cedar: Differences, Uses and Durability

Last Updated on: October 8, 2026

Incense cedar is harder than western red cedar, but that does not automatically make it more resistant to rot or better for outdoor use. Both are lightweight softwoods with workable grain and naturally decay-resistant heartwood.

Incense cedar is especially associated with pencil manufacturing, while western red cedar is widely used for siding, shingles, decking, and outdoor structures. Either can be useful for woodworking when the lumber grade and construction suit the project.

The main differences involve hardness, appearance, available products, and local cost—not a simple rule that one species is better in every situation.

What Is Incense Cedar?

Incense cedar (Calocedrus decurrens) is an evergreen conifer native to western North America, including parts of the western United States and northern Baja California.

Its lumber is light, aromatic, and generally straight-grained, with a fine, relatively uniform texture. These characteristics make it useful for small manufactured items as well as selected interior and exterior applications.

Although it is sometimes called “white cedar,” that name is shared with other trees. Use the scientific name when confirming the species with a supplier.

Incense cedar produces cones rather than flowers. It belongs to the cypress family and is not a true cedar of the genus Cedrus.

What Is Western Red Cedar?

Western red cedar (Thuja plicata) is an evergreen conifer native to western North America. Its natural range includes the Pacific Northwest and inland populations.

The wood is lightweight, aromatic, and typically straight-grained. Its combination of workability, dimensional stability, and heartwood decay resistance makes it useful for exterior building products.

Western red cedar also belongs to the cypress family rather than the true cedar genus.

It should not be confused with eastern red cedar, the wood commonly associated with aromatic closet linings and cedar chests.

Incense Cedar vs Western Red Cedar: Quick Comparison

CharacteristicIncense cedarWestern red cedar
Scientific nameCalocedrus decurrensThuja plicata
Wood classificationSoftwoodSoftwood
Typical Janka hardnessAbout 470 lbfAbout 350 lbf
Typical heartwood colorLight to medium reddish-brownPinkish-brown to reddish or darker brown
SapwoodPale, often nearly whitePale, often nearly white
GrainUsually straightUsually straight
TextureFine and relatively uniformGenerally coarser than incense cedar
Natural decay resistanceDurable heartwood; sapwood is less resistantDurable heartwood; sapwood is less resistant
Familiar usesPencils, blinds, siding, trim, and specialty productsSiding, shingles, decking, fencing, and outdoor structures
PriceDepends on grade, dimensions, and locationDepends on grade, dimensions, and location

Hardness figures are typical reference values rather than guarantees for individual boards.

Appearance and Color

Incense Cedar

Incense cedar heartwood generally ranges from light to medium reddish-brown. Its pale sapwood can create a visible contrast, although the difference varies between boards.

The relatively fine texture suits projects where a smooth, understated surface is desirable.

Western Red Cedar

Western red cedar can show considerable color variation. One board may be pale brown, while another has deeper reddish or chocolate-brown tones.

This variation can be attractive on siding and fences, but it may require careful board selection if you want a uniform appearance.

Color alone is not a reliable way to distinguish the two woods. Finishing, weathering, and variation within each species can make identification difficult.

For more on the light and dark regions within a board, see our guide to heartwood vs sapwood.

Which One Is Harder?

Incense cedar has a typical Janka hardness of approximately 470 lbf, compared with approximately 350 lbf for western red cedar.

That gives incense cedar greater resistance to indentation in the standard test. However, both remain relatively soft woods and can dent under concentrated pressure.

The USDA’s Softwoods of North America reference describes incense cedar as lightweight and relatively low in hardness and several mechanical properties. Its higher hardness compared with western red cedar should not be mistaken for hardwood-like wear resistance. USDA softwood reference

For a bench, tabletop, or other frequently handled surface, consider the likely wear. A protective coating cannot prevent every dent in the wood beneath it.

Which Is More Rot-Resistant?

Both species have heartwood with useful natural decay resistance. Neither should be described as universally superior without considering the material and exposure.

Outdoor performance depends on:

  • The proportion of heartwood and sapwood.
  • Whether the wood remains damp.
  • Ground contact.
  • Drainage and ventilation.
  • Lumber condition and construction details.

Sapwood does not offer the same natural durability as the heartwood. A board containing a large amount of sapwood may perform differently from an all-heartwood board of the same species.

Neither wood is waterproof, and natural decay resistance does not mean immunity to insects or fungi.

Common Uses of Incense Cedar

Pencils

Incense cedar is especially well known for pencil stock. Its grain and machining characteristics allow pencil casings to be manufactured and sharpened cleanly.

Blinds and Interior Components

Its low weight and workability make it useful for blinds, trim, and selected decorative components.

Siding and Exterior Products

Suitable incense cedar lumber is used for siding, fencing, and other outdoor applications. Confirm the grade and product specification rather than assuming every board is appropriate.

Small Woodworking Projects

Boxes and decorative objects can benefit from its manageable weight and fine texture. Use sharp tools and support delicate edges to avoid crushing or tearing the fibers.

Common Uses of Western Red Cedar

Siding, Shingles, and Shakes

Western red cedar is available in a range of established exterior profiles and grades. Product selection should match the desired appearance and installation requirements.

Decking and Fencing

It is used for deck boards, fence components, and privacy screens. Its softness means wear and impact damage remain possible, particularly on heavily used decks.

Pergolas and Outdoor Structures

Its low weight can simplify handling, but load-bearing members still need the correct grade, dimensions, and connections.

Specialty Products

Selected western red cedar is also used in boatbuilding and musical instruments, including some soundboards. These applications require appropriate material selection rather than ordinary construction-grade boards.

Workability: Which Is Easier to Use?

Both woods are generally manageable with hand and power tools.

Incense cedar’s finer texture can be useful for detailed machining. Western red cedar also cuts readily, but its soft fibers require care to obtain clean edges.

For either species:

  • Use sharp cutting tools.
  • Support the wood near the cut.
  • Avoid excessive clamping pressure.
  • Pre-drill where needed near ends or edges.
  • Test the finish on an offcut.

Wood dust should be controlled with extraction and suitable protection. Easy machining does not mean dust exposure should be ignored.

Stability and Drying

Both species are valued for dimensional stability, but neither is immune to movement.

Poorly dried lumber, uneven wetting, unsuitable storage, and restrictive fastening can still contribute to distortion or checking.

Choose lumber at an appropriate moisture condition for the project and allow for movement in the design. A species reputation cannot compensate for wet boards installed incorrectly.

Price and Availability

Incense cedar may be economical where it is locally processed, while western red cedar may offer a broader choice of ready-made exterior products in some markets.

There is no reliable universal rule that incense cedar always costs less.

Compare equivalent:

  • Grades and appearance requirements.
  • Dimensions and usable lengths.
  • Moisture condition.
  • Surface preparation.
  • Heartwood requirements.
  • Delivery and waste allowances.

A cheaper rough board may not save money if it requires substantial machining to match a finished siding product.

Finishing and Fasteners

Choose a finish intended for the application. A coating suitable for vertical siding may not be appropriate for a walking surface.

If preserving color matters, expect ongoing maintenance. Unfinished exterior wood weathers, and sheltered areas may change differently from exposed areas.

Use corrosion-resistant fasteners compatible with the wood, coating, and location. Ordinary steel can cause staining and deteriorate in exterior service. For western red cedar, consult the Real Cedar fastener guidance.

Also check installation instructions for spacing, end treatment, and any coating requirements.

Which Wood Should You Choose?

Project priorityPractical choice
Pencil making or fine-textured small componentsIncense cedar is an established option
Ready-made siding, shingles, or deckingCompare available western red cedar products with local alternatives
Slightly greater dent resistanceIncense cedar has the higher typical Janka value
Untreated outdoor durabilityPrioritize suitable heartwood and sound detailing in either species
Lowest project costCompare equivalent local products
Structural performanceChoose graded lumber that meets the design requirements

For outdoor projects, the quality of the boards and installation often matters more than the modest hardness difference.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Incense Cedar More Durable Than Western Red Cedar?

Not automatically. It is harder in the Janka test, but hardness and decay resistance are different properties. Both have durable heartwood.

Are They Hardwoods or Softwoods?

Both are softwoods because they come from coniferous trees.

Can Either Wood Be Used Outdoors Without Treatment?

Suitable heartwood can be used in some untreated outdoor applications. Exposure and construction matter, and ground-contact applications require particular care when selecting material.

Is Western Red Cedar the Best Wood for a Closet?

Do not confuse western red cedar with eastern red cedar. Eastern red cedar is the species commonly sold for aromatic closet lining. Confirm the product’s identity and intended use.

Can You Paint or Stain Both Woods?

Yes. Prepare the surface and use a compatible system. Where extractive staining is a concern under paint, follow the coating manufacturer’s primer recommendations.

Comments are closed.